// Copyright (C) 2025 Gradle, Inc.
//
// Licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.;
// you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
// You may obtain a copy of the License at
//
//      https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/
//
// Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
// distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
// WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
// See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
// limitations under the License.

[[verifying-dependencies]]
= Verifying Dependencies

Working with external dependencies and plugins from third-party repositories exposes your build to significant supply chain risks.
Dependencies are the most commonly attacked part of the software supply chain, and every artifact you consume, including transitively pulled-in binaries, needs to be both legitimate and unchanged.

To illustrate the risk, consider building an application that uses the `trusty-lib:1.0` library from a public repository.
If an attacker successfully replaces `trusty-lib` in the repository with a malicious version having the same coordinates (`trusty-lib:1.0`), your next build will download the compromised code without any warning.

To mitigate these risks and avoid integrating compromised artifacts, Gradle provides *dependency verification*.

But dependency verification adds overhead: *So why keep it on?*

Because dependency verification is about *trust*: trust that what you download is what you think it is, and that what you ship is what you intended.

Without verification, it is easier for attackers to compromise your supply chain by publishing malicious artifacts under trusted coordinates or by tampering with artifacts in transit or at rest.
Dependency verification helps protect you from these attacks by requiring you to confirm that the artifacts used in your build are the ones you expect.

Finding the right balance between security and convenience is hard, but Gradle provides options to let you choose the right level for your needs.

NOTE: Dependency verification is meant to protect yourself from compromised dependencies, not to prevent you from including _vulnerable_ dependencies.

[[understanding_verification_methods]]
== Understanding Verification Methods

Gradle provides two complementary mechanisms for dependency verification:

1. *Checksums* – Verify the *integrity* of the artifact (that file contents haven't changed)
2. *Signatures* – Verify the *provenance* of the artifact (who published it)

Used together, they help ensure you get the right library or plugin from a trustworthy author.
Checksums alone verify integrity but not authenticity.
Signatures alone verify authenticity but may use weak hashes.
You can use signatures whenever they are available, and fall back to checksums when artifacts are not signed.
**But for the strongest security, use both.**

WARNING: Signatures can also be used to assess integrity like checksums, but signatures are an _encrypted hash_ of the artifact contents and some metadata, not artifacts themselves.
If the signature uses an unsafe hash (even `SHA-1`), you're not correctly assessing file integrity.
For this reason, if you care about both integrity and authenticity, you need to add both signatures _and_ checksums to your verification metadata.

[[sec:checksum-verification]]
=== Checksums

A checksum is a short *fingerprint* of a file's contents.

To produce a checksum, the library or plugin file is passed through a cryptographic hash function (for example, `SHA-256`), which returns a fixed-length string that uniquely represents that exact content.
If the file changes in any way, the checksum will also change.

With *checksums*, the build tool keeps a list of expected hashes for each artifact:

* You record the expected checksum (for example, `SHA-256`) of a library or plugin in the `gradle/verification-metadata.xml` file.
* When the build downloads that artifact, it computes the checksum of the downloaded bytes.
* If the computed checksum doesn't match the expected value, the build fails instead of using the tampered file.

For example, the checksum entry for `trusty-lib-1.0.jar` might look like this:

[source,xml]
.verification-metadata.xml
----
<artifact name="trusty-lib-1.0.jar">
    <sha256 value="5e87d84077de0c60d9ff4eedbc9fac1506693019eb6f55652afc9e1ff235bd15"/>
</artifact>
----

[[sec:signature-verification]]
=== Signatures

A signature is a cryptographic *stamp* that proves authenticity.

To produce a signature, the author uses their *private key* to create a digital signature over the library or plugin.

With *signatures*, you verify *who* produced the artifact, not just that it hasn't changed:

* The author signs the checksum of the artifact's file contents along with additional metadata using their private key.
* You verify and add trusted public keys to the `gradle/verification-metadata.xml` file.
* When the artifact is downloaded, the build verifies the signature against the trusted public key.
* If the signature is missing, invalid, or signed by an untrusted key, the build fails.

For example, the combined checksum and signature entry for `trusty-lib-1.0.jar` might look like this:

[source,xml]
.verification-metadata.xml
----
<artifact name="trusty-lib-1.0.jar">
    <sha256 value="5e87d84077de0c60d9ff4eedbc9fac1506693019eb6f55652afc9e1ff235bd15"/>
    <pgp value="D4C89EA4AAF455FD88B22087EFE8086F9E93774E"/>
</artifact>
----

[[trusted-keys]]
=== Trusted Keys and Key Servers

Because public keys are part of the verification process, Gradle records trusted public key IDs in `verification-metadata.xml` on a group-level basis:

[source,xml]
.verification-metadata.xml
----
<trusted-keys>
    <trusted-key
        id="06D34ED6FF73DE368A772A781063FE98BCECB758"
        group="com.puppycrawl.tools"
        name="checkstyle"/>
</trusted-keys>
----

Public keys are typically fetched from key servers, which are repositories for public keys, such as:

* https://keyserver.ubuntu.com
* https://keys.openpgp.org
* https://pgp.mit.edu

Gradle uses these trusted keys plus the checksum/signature data in `verification-metadata.xml` to ensure that dependencies come from the expected author and have not been tampered with.

[[sub:enabling-verification]]
== Enabling Dependency Verification

To enable dependency verification, you need to create a verification metadata file that tells Gradle which checksums and signatures to verify.
Once this file exists, Gradle automatically verifies all dependencies during every build.

[[sub:verification-metadata]]
=== The Verification Metadata File

Dependency verification is automatically enabled as soon as the verification metadata file is detected.
The file must be located at `$PROJECT_ROOT/gradle/verification-metadata.xml`.

NOTE: Currently, the only source of dependency verification metadata is this XML configuration file. Future versions of Gradle may include other sources (for example, via external services).

A minimal configuration consists of the following:

[source,xml]
----
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<verification-metadata xmlns="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification"
      xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
      xsi:schemaLocation="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification/dependency-verification-1.3.xsd">
   <configuration>
      <verify-metadata>true</verify-metadata>
      <verify-signatures>false</verify-signatures>
    </configuration>
</verification-metadata>
----

With this configuration, Gradle verifies all artifacts using checksums but will not verify signatures.

Gradle verifies any artifact downloaded via its dependency management engine, including but not limited to:

- Artifact files (e.g., JAR files, ZIPs) used during the build
- Metadata artifacts (POM files, Ivy descriptors, and Gradle Module Metadata)
- Plugins (both project and settings plugins)
- Artifacts resolved via advanced dependency resolution APIs

Gradle does _not_ verify changing dependencies (specifically `SNAPSHOT` versions) or locally produced artifacts (such as JARs generated during the build itself).
By nature, the checksums and signatures of these files change constantly.

WARNING: Using such a minimal configuration file will cause a project with external dependencies or plugins to fail immediately, as the file does not yet contain the required checksums for verification. See <<#sec:bootstrapping-verification>> to learn more.

[[sec:verification-scope]]
=== Scope of Dependency Verification

The dependency verification configuration is _global_; a single file is used to verify the entire build.
Specifically, the same file applies to all subprojects, the root project, and `buildSrc`.

When using an included build, the following rules apply:

- The configuration file of the _current_ build is used for verification.
- If an included build has its own verification metadata, that configuration is ignored in favor of the _current_ build's settings.
- Much like upgrading a dependency, including a new build may require you to update your _current_ verification metadata.

Because this configuration is global and strict, the most efficient way to begin is by generating a baseline configuration for your existing build.

[[sec:disabling-metadata-verification]]
== Disabling Dependency Verification

By default, Gradle verifies both artifacts (JARs, ZIPs, etc.) and their metadata files (POM files, Ivy descriptors, Gradle Module Metadata).
Metadata verification can significantly increase the size of your configuration file.

To disable metadata verification, set the `<verify-metadata>` flag to `false`:

[source,xml]
----
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<verification-metadata xmlns="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification"
      xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
      xsi:schemaLocation="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification/dependency-verification-1.3.xsd">
   <configuration>
      <verify-metadata>false</verify-metadata>
      <verify-signatures>false</verify-signatures>
    </configuration>
</verification-metadata>
----

WARNING: Disabling metadata verification reduces security. Compromised metadata files could introduce malicious transitive dependencies into your build.

[[sub:disabling-specific-verification]]
=== Disabling Verification for Specific Configurations

Dependency verification is enabled globally to provide the strongest security level possible.
However, plugins may need to resolve additional dependencies where verification doesn't make sense.

For example, a plugin might check for newer versions of a library.
It doesn't make sense to require checksums for versions you don't know about yet. In these cases, you can disable verification for specific configurations using the API.

WARNING: Disabling dependency verification reduces security. This API exists for cases where verification doesn't make sense. Gradle will print a warning whenever verification has been disabled for a specific configuration.

To disable verification for a configuration, use the `ResolutionStrategy#disableDependencyVerification` method:

====
include::sample[dir="snippets/securing-builds/dependencyVerification-disableVerification/kotlin",files="build.gradle.kts[tags=disable-verification]"]
include::sample[dir="snippets/securing-builds/dependencyVerification-disableVerification/groovy",files="build.gradle[tags=disable-verification]"]
====

You can also disable verification on detached configurations:

====
[.multi-language-sample]
=====
[source,kotlin]
----
val detached = configurations.detachedConfiguration(dependencies.create("group:name:1.0"))
detached.resolutionStrategy.disableDependencyVerification()
----
=====
[.multi-language-sample]
=====
[source,groovy]
----
def detached = configurations.detachedConfiguration(dependencies.create("group:name:1.0"))
detached.resolutionStrategy.disableDependencyVerification()
----
=====
====

[[sec:skipping-javadocs]]
=== Skipping Javadocs and Sources

By default, Gradle verifies all downloaded artifacts, including javadocs and sources.
This can cause issues with IDEs that automatically download them during import.

To avoid this, you can configure Gradle to automatically trust all javadocs and sources:

[source,xml]
----
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<verification-metadata xmlns="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification"
      xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
      xsi:schemaLocation="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification/dependency-verification-1.3.xsd">
   <configuration>
      <trusted-artifacts>
         <trust file=".*-javadoc[.]jar" regex="true"/>
         <trust file=".*-sources[.]jar" regex="true"/>
      </trusted-artifacts>
   </configuration>
</verification-metadata>
----

The `<trusted-artifacts>` section uses regular expressions to match artifact filenames.
Any artifacts matching these patterns will be automatically trusted without verification.

NOTE: Trusting javadoc and source artifacts means they could be tampered with without detection.

[[sec:disabling-verification]]
== Verification Modes

Dependency verification can be expensive, or sometimes verification gets in the way of day-to-day development (frequent dependency upgrades, for example).
You might want to enable verification on CI servers but not on local machines.

Gradle provides three verification modes:

[cols="1,3"]
|===
|Mode |Description

|`strict` (default)
|Verification fails as early as possible to avoid using compromised dependencies during the build

|`lenient`
|Runs the build even if there are verification failures. Verification errors are displayed without causing build failure

|`off`
|Verification is completely ignored
|===

You can activate these modes on the CLI using the `--dependency-verification` flag:

[source,bash]
----
$ ./gradlew --dependency-verification lenient build
----

Alternatively, set the `org.gradle.dependency.verification` system property on the CLI:

[source,bash]
----
$ ./gradlew -Dorg.gradle.dependency.verification=lenient build
----

Or in a `gradle.properties` file:

[source,properties]
----
org.gradle.dependency.verification=lenient
----

[[sec:verification-console-output]]
== Configuring the Console Output

By default, if dependency verification fails, Gradle generates a small summary about the verification failure as well as an HTML report containing the full information about the failures.

If your environment prevents you from reading this HTML report file (for example, if you run a build on CI, and it's not easy to fetch the remote artifacts), Gradle provides a way to opt in to a verbose console report.

Add this Gradle property to your `gradle.properties` file:

[source,properties]
----
org.gradle.dependency.verification.console=verbose
----

[[sec:bootstrapping-verification]]
== Generating and Bootstrapping Verification Metadata

Gradle can automatically generate a dependency verification file by downloading all your dependencies and recording their checksums or signatures.
This is called *bootstrapping*.

However, bootstrapping has a critical security limitation: **it trusts whatever is currently in your repositories**.
If a malicious dependency has already been introduced into your build (or into a repository you use), Gradle will record the compromised artifact's checksum or signature.

This is why you must **review the generated verification file**.
Bootstrapping is convenient for getting started or updating your verification file, but it's not a substitute for manual verification of critical dependencies.

[[generating_checksums_only]]
=== Generating Checksums Only

To enable checksum verification, you need to generate a configuration file based on your current, trusted dependencies.

Run the following command in your terminal:

[source,bash]
----
$ ./gradlew --write-verification-metadata sha256
----

What this does:

1. It scans all the dependencies in your project.
2. It calculates the `SHA-256` checksum for each.
3. It creates a file located at `gradle/verification-metadata.xml`.

Gradle supports `MD5`, `SHA1`, `SHA-256`, and `SHA-512` checksums.
However, only `SHA-256` and `SHA-512` are considered secure for modern use.
`SHA-1` has known collisions and `MD5` should not be used.

[[generating_checksums_and_signatures]]
=== Generating Checksums and Signatures

To generate both checksums and signatures (recommended when signatures are available), run:

[source,bash]
----
$ ./gradlew --write-verification-metadata sha256,pgp
----

Gradle will:

* Resolve your dependencies.
* Download and/or generate the required verification information.
* Write it in a VCS-friendly XML file at `gradle/verification-metadata.xml`.

The `write-verification-metadata` flag requires the list of checksums that you want to generate or `pgp` for signatures.

Executing this command will cause Gradle to:

* Resolve all resolvable configurations, which includes:
** Configurations from the root project
** Configurations from all subprojects
** Configurations from `buildSrc`
** Included builds configurations
** Configurations used by plugins
* Download all artifacts discovered during resolution
* Compute the requested checksums and possibly verify signatures depending on what you asked
* At the end of the build, generate the configuration file which will contain the inferred _verification metadata_

Gradle only supports verification of signatures published as ASCII-armored PGP files (`.asc`) on remote repositories.
Not all artifacts are published with signatures, and signature verification doesn't guarantee the signatory was legitimate—only that the artifact was signed by a specific key.

[[example_verification_metadata_file]]
=== Example Verification Metadata File

A snippet of the resulting `verification-metadata.xml` looks like this:

[source,xml]
.verification-metadata.xml
----
<verification-metadata
    xmlns="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification"
    xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
    xsi:schemaLocation="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification/dependency-verification-1.3.xsd">

    <components>

        <!-- BOTH SIGNATURE AND CHECKSUM -->
        <component group="com.google.guava" name="failureaccess" version="1.0.3">
            <artifact name="failureaccess-1.0.3.jar">
                <pgp value="BDB5FA4FE719D787FB3D3197F6D4A1D411E9D1AE"/>
                <sha256 value="cbfc3906b19b8f55dd7cfd6dfe0aa4532e834250d7f080bd8d211a3e246b59cb"
                        origin="Verified"
                        reason="Added manually to fix CI"/>
            </artifact>
        </component>

        <!-- CHECKSUM ONLY -->
        <component group="antlr" name="antlr" version="2.7.7">
            <artifact name="antlr-2.7.7.jar">
                <sha256 value="88fbda4b912596b9f56e8e12e580cc954bacfb51776ecfddd3e18fc1cf56dc4c"
                        origin="Verified"
                        reason="Artifact is not signed"/>
            </artifact>
        </component>

        <!-- SIGNATURE ONLY -->
        <component group="com.beust" name="jcommander" version="1.78">
            <artifact name="jcommander-1.78.jar">
                <pgp value="C70B844F002F21F6D2B9C87522E44AC0622B91C3"/>
                <pgp value="DCBA03381EF6C89096ACD985AC5EC74981F9CDA6"/>
            </artifact>
        </component>

    </components>
</verification-metadata>
----

[[sec:verification-dry-mode]]
=== Dry-Run Mode

By default, bootstrapping is incremental, which means that if you run it multiple times, information is _added_ to the file.
You can rely on your version control system to check the diffs between runs.

There are situations where you want to preview what the generated verification metadata file would look like without actually changing or overwriting the existing one.

To preview changes, add the `--dry-run` flag:

[source,bash]
----
$ ./gradlew --write-verification-metadata sha256 help --dry-run
----

Instead of generating the `verification-metadata.xml` file, Gradle will create a new file called `verification-metadata.dryrun.xml` that you can review.

NOTE: Because `--dry-run` doesn't execute tasks, it runs much faster but will miss any dependency resolution that happens at task execution time.

[[updating_verification_metadata]]
== Updating Verification Metadata

Once the `verification-metadata.xml` file is generated, every time a developer or CI server runs the build, Gradle will compare the downloaded file's checksum against the one in the XML file.

When you add a new library or update a version, the build will fail because the new checksum isn't in your XML file yet.

You have two options for updating the verification metadata: <<#sec:manual-update-metadata,auto-update>> or <<#sec:verification-update,manual update>>.

[[sec:verification-update]]
=== Updating Verification Metadata Automatically

Run the `--write-verification-metadata` command again to append the new hashes:

[source,bash]
----
$ ./gradlew --write-verification-metadata sha256
----

Bootstrapping can either be used to create the file from the beginning or to _update_ an existing file with new information.
Therefore, it's recommended to always use the same parameters once you started bootstrapping.

Generation is incremental and preserves existing entries.
Gradle-generated checksums will have an `origin` attribute starting with `"Generated by Gradle"` to indicate they need review.
Manually added entries and header comments are preserved, making it easy to update the file for new dependency versions by regenerating and reviewing the diff.

[source,xml]
.verification-metadata.xml
----
<verification-metadata
    xmlns="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification"
    xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
    xsi:schemaLocation="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification/dependency-verification-1.3.xsd">

    <components>
      <component group="aopalliance" name="aopalliance" version="1.0">
         <artifact name="aopalliance-1.0.jar">
            <sha256 value="0addec670fedcd3f113c5c8091d783280d23f75e3acb841b61a9cdb079376a08" origin="Generated by Gradle" reason="Artifact is not signed"/>
         </artifact>
         <artifact name="aopalliance-1.0.pom">
            <sha256 value="26e82330157d6b844b67a8064945e206581e772977183e3e31fec6058aa9a59b" origin="Generated by Gradle" reason="Artifact is not signed"/>
         </artifact>
      </component>
    </components>
</verification-metadata>
----

After regenerating the file, follow these steps:

1. *Review the diff* - Check what changed in your version control system.
2. *Remove unnecessary entries* - Delete entries for old dependency versions that are no longer used.
3. *Verify new entries* - Ensure new checksums are correct by checking against official sources when possible.
4. *Handle ignored keys* - If any ignored keys were added, attempt to download them from a keyserver and add them to the keyring if found. See <<#sec:add-ascii-keyring,adding keys to the keyring>>.
5. *Update all "Generated by Gradle" origins* - You must review and update all entries with `origin="Generated by Gradle"`. Common reasons for generation include:
* Artifact is not signed
* PGP signature verification failed
* Key couldn't be downloaded
6. *Change origin to "Verified"* - After verifying the checksum matches, edit the `origin` attribute to `"Verified"` to indicate you've confirmed it.

IMPORTANT: Gradle cannot automatically determine that an entry is outdated. Remove older entries when you upgrade dependencies to keep the file manageable.

WARNING: There are dependencies that Gradle _cannot_ discover automatically. In particular, dependencies that are only resolved during task execution or in custom dependency resolution logic may not be included in the generated file. You may need to add these manually.

[[sec:manual-update-metadata]]
=== Updating Verification Metadata Manually

You can add a new `<component>` entry for a checksum or signature to the XML file manually.

[[adding_checksums_for_an_artifact]]
==== Adding Checksums for an Artifact

External components are identified by GAV coordinates (`group`, artifact `name`, `version`), and each artifact by its file name.

For example, to add verification for https://pdfbox.apache.org[Apache PDFBox] with GAV coordinates:

- group: `org.apache.pdfbox`
- name: `pdfbox`
- version: `2.0.17`

Using this dependency triggers the download of two files:

- `pdfbox-2.0.17.jar` - the main artifact
- `pdfbox-2.0.17.pom` - the metadata file

You need to declare checksums for both (unless you <<sec:disabling-metadata-verification,disabled metadata verification>>):

[source,xml]
----
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<verification-metadata xmlns="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification"
      xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
      xsi:schemaLocation="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification/dependency-verification-1.3.xsd">
   <configuration>
      <verify-metadata>true</verify-metadata>
      <verify-signatures>false</verify-signatures>
   </configuration>
   <components>
      <component group="org.apache.pdfbox" name="pdfbox" version="2.0.17">
         <artifact name="pdfbox-2.0.17.jar">
            <sha512 value="7e11e54a21c395d461e59552e88b0de0ebaf1bf9d9bcacadf17b240d9bbc29bf6beb8e36896c186fe405d287f5d517b02c89381aa0fcc5e0aa5814e44f0ab331" origin="PDFBox Official site (https://pdfbox.apache.org/download.cgi)"/>
         </artifact>
         <artifact name="pdfbox-2.0.17.pom">
            <sha512 value="82de436b38faf6121d8d2e71dda06e79296fc0f7bc7aba0766728c8d306fd1b0684b5379c18808ca724bf91707277eba81eb4fe19518e99e8f2a56459b79742f" origin="Verified"/>
         </artifact>
      </component>
   </components>
</verification-metadata>
----

[[where_to_get_checksums]]
===== Where to Get Checksums

Checksums are generally published alongside artifacts on public repositories.
However, if a dependency is compromised in a repository, its checksum likely is too.

It's a good practice to get checksums from a different source than where artifacts are hosted (typically the library's official website).
It's much harder to compromise both the repository and the official website simultaneously.

In the example above, the checksum for the JAR was found on the official PDFBox website, while the POM checksum was verified manually.
The `origin` attribute documents where the checksum came from, helping others understand how trustworthy the verification is.

[[using_multiple_checksums]]
===== Using Multiple Checksums

You can declare multiple checksums for the same artifact.
Gradle will verify _all_ of them and fail if _any_ verification fails.

[source,xml]
----
<component group="org.apache.pdfbox" name="pdfbox" version="2.0.17">
   <artifact name="pdfbox-2.0.17.jar">
      <md5 value="c713a8e252d0add65e9282b151adf6b4" origin="official site"/>
      <sha1 value="b5c8dff799bd967c70ccae75e6972327ae640d35" origin="official site"/>
   </artifact>
</component>
----

Use multiple checksums when:

* The official site only publishes insecure checksums (MD5, SHA-1). While each can be faked individually, faking multiple checksums for the same artifact is harder.
* You want to add generated checksums alongside manually verified ones for extra validation.
* You're upgrading to more secure checksums but don't want to remove existing ones yet.

[[handling_transitive_dependencies]]
===== Handling Transitive Dependencies

Using a dependency like `pdfbox` will bring in transitive dependencies.
If your verification file only includes checksums for direct dependencies, the build will fail:

[source,text]
----
Execution failed for task ':compileJava'.
> Dependency verification failed for configuration ':compileClasspath':
    - On artifact commons-logging-1.2.jar (commons-logging:commons-logging:1.2) in repository 'MavenRepo': checksum is missing from verification metadata.
    - On artifact commons-logging-1.2.pom (commons-logging:commons-logging:1.2) in repository 'MavenRepo': checksum is missing from verification metadata.
----

This indicates you need to add checksums for `commons-logging` and all other transitive dependencies.
See <<#sec:dealing-verification-failure>> for more details.

[[sec:trusting-several-checksums]]
===== Trusting Multiple Checksums

It's common to have different checksums for the same artifact in different repositories.
This can happen because:

* Developers publish to Maven Central and another repository separately using different builds
* Metadata files differ slightly (different timestamps, additional whitespace, etc.)
* Your build uses multiple repositories or repository mirrors

Despite progress, this is often not malicious.
In general, you should verify the artifact is correct, then declare the additional checksums using `also-trust`:

[source,xml]
----
<component group="org.apache" name="apache" version="13">
   <artifact name="apache-13.pom">
      <sha256 value="2fafa38abefe1b40283016f506ba9e844bfcf18713497284264166a5dbf4b95e">
         <also-trust value="ff513db0361fd41237bef4784968bc15aae478d4ec0a9496f811072ccaf3841d"/>
      </sha256>
   </artifact>
</component>
----

You can have as many `also-trust` entries as needed, though typically you shouldn't need more than two.

[[adding_keys_for_an_artifact]]
==== Adding Keys for an Artifact

To trust a key for signature verification, add a `pgp` entry to your verification metadata:

[source,xml]
----
<component group="com.github.javaparser" name="javaparser-core" version="3.6.11">
   <artifact name="javaparser-core-3.6.11.jar">
      <pgp value="8756c4f765c9ac3cb6b85d62379ce192d401ab61"/>
   </artifact>
</component>
----

This means you trust `com.github.javaparser:javaparser-core:3.6.11` if it's signed with key `8756c4f765c9ac3cb6b85d62379ce192d401ab61`.

Without trusted keys configured, the build will fail:

[source,text]
----
> Dependency verification failed for configuration ':compileClasspath':
    - On artifact javaparser-core-3.6.11.jar (com.github.javaparser:javaparser-core:3.6.11) in repository 'MavenRepo': Artifact was signed with key '8756c4f765c9ac3cb6b85d62379ce192d401ab61' (Bintray (by JFrog) <****>) and passed verification but the key isn't in your trusted keys list.
----

WARNING: Gradle requires full fingerprint IDs (40 characters, e.g., `b801e2f8ef035068ec1139cc29579f18fa8fd93b`) for `pgp` and `trusted-key` elements, not short or long IDs. This minimizes the risk of collision attacks. For `ignored-key` elements, you can use either fingerprints or long (64-bit) IDs.

NOTE: The key IDs shown in error messages are from the signature file itself. This doesn't necessarily mean you should trust them—if a malicious entity signed the artifact, Gradle won't detect that. Always verify keys against official sources.

[[sec:trusting-keys-globally]]
==== Adding Global Keys

Signature verification can be simplified by trusting keys at the group level instead of declaring them for each individual artifact.
This is useful when the same key signs multiple artifacts from the same publisher.

You can add trusted keys to a global configuration block:

[source,xml]
----
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<verification-metadata xmlns="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification"
      xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
      xsi:schemaLocation="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification/dependency-verification-1.3.xsd">
   <configuration>
      <verify-metadata>true</verify-metadata>
      <verify-signatures>true</verify-signatures>
      <trusted-keys>
         <trusted-key id="8756c4f765c9ac3cb6b85d62379ce192d401ab61" group="com.github.javaparser"/>
      </trusted-keys>
   </configuration>
   <components/>
</verification-metadata>
----

This configuration trusts any artifact in the `com.github.javaparser` group if it's signed with key `8756c4f765c9ac3cb6b85d62379ce192d401ab61`.

The `trusted-key` element supports these attributes:

* `group` - the group of the artifact to trust
* `name` - the name of the artifact to trust
* `version` - the version of the artifact to trust
* `file` - the name of the artifact file to trust
* `regex` - whether to interpret the other attributes as regular expressions (defaults to `false`)

[[security_considerations]]
===== Security Considerations

Be careful when trusting keys globally:

* A valid key may have been used to sign artifact `A` which you trust
* Later, the key could be stolen and used to sign malicious artifact `B`

This means you should limit trust to appropriate groups or artifacts, and avoid trusting keys too broadly.

IMPORTANT: Anyone can put an arbitrary name when generating a PGP key. Never trust a key solely based on its name. Always verify the key is listed on the official project website. For example, Apache projects typically provide a `KEYS.txt` file.

[[sec:trusting-artifacts]]
==== Adding Trusted Artifacts

You might want to trust some artifacts more than others.
For example, it's legitimate to think that artifacts produced in your company and found in your internal repository are safe, but you want to check every external component.

NOTE: This is a typical company policy. However, nothing prevents your internal repository from being compromised, so it's a good idea to check your internal artifacts too!

You can automatically trust all artifacts in a group by adding this to your configuration:

[source,xml]
----
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<verification-metadata xmlns="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification"
      xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
      xsi:schemaLocation="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification/dependency-verification-1.3.xsd">
   <configuration>
      <trusted-artifacts>
         <trust group="com.mycompany" reason="We trust mycompany artifacts"/>
      </trusted-artifacts>
   </configuration>
</verification-metadata>
----

This means all components with group `com.mycompany` will be automatically trusted.
Trusted means Gradle will not perform any verification whatsoever.

The `trust` element accepts these attributes:

* `group` - the group of the artifact to trust
* `name` - the name of the artifact to trust
* `version` - the version of the artifact to trust
* `file` - the name of the artifact file to trust
* `regex` - whether to interpret the `group`, `name`, `version`, and `file` attributes as regular expressions (defaults to `false`)
* `reason` - an optional reason why matched artifacts are trusted

In the example above, this trusts artifacts in `com.mycompany` but not `com.mycompany.other`.
To trust all artifacts in `com.mycompany` and all subgroups, you can use:

[source,xml]
----
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<verification-metadata xmlns="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification"
      xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
      xsi:schemaLocation="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification/dependency-verification-1.3.xsd">
   <configuration>
      <trusted-artifacts>
         <trust group="^com[.]mycompany($|([.].*))" regex="true" reason="We trust all mycompany artifacts"/>
      </trusted-artifacts>
   </configuration>
</verification-metadata>
----

[[sec:ignoring-keys]]
=== Configuring Key Servers, Keyrings, and Keys

[[specifying_key_servers]]
==== Specifying Key Servers

Gradle automatically downloads public keys from well-known key servers.
You can configure custom key servers by adding them to your verification metadata:

[source,xml]
----
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<verification-metadata xmlns="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification"
      xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
      xsi:schemaLocation="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification/dependency-verification-1.3.xsd">
   <configuration>
      <verify-metadata>true</verify-metadata>
      <verify-signatures>true</verify-signatures>
      <key-servers>
         <key-server uri="hkp://my-key-server.org"/>
         <key-server uri="https://my-other-key-server.org"/>
      </key-servers>
   </configuration>
</verification-metadata>
----

[[sec:local-keyring-only]]
==== Using Local Keyrings Only

The local keyring files (`.gpg` or `.keys`) can be used to avoid reaching out to key servers whenever a key is required.
However, if the local keyring doesn't contain a key, Gradle would normally use key servers to fetch the missing key.

If the local keyring file isn't regularly updated, your CI builds (especially with disposable containers) might reach out to key servers too often.

To avoid this, you can disable key servers entirely.
Only the local keyring file will be used, and if a key is missing, the build will fail.

To enable this mode, disable key servers in the configuration file:

[source,xml]
----
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<verification-metadata xmlns="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification"
      xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
      xsi:schemaLocation="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification/dependency-verification-1.3.xsd">
   <configuration>
      <key-servers enabled="false"/>
   </configuration>
</verification-metadata>
----

NOTE: If you are asking Gradle to generate verification metadata and an existing file sets `enabled` to `false`, this flag will be ignored so that potentially missing keys can be downloaded.

[[ignoring_unavailable_keys]]
==== Ignoring Unavailable Keys

Sometimes a key is not available because it wasn't published to a public key server or was lost.
In these cases, you can ignore the key:

[source,xml]
----
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<verification-metadata xmlns="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification"
      xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
      xsi:schemaLocation="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification/dependency-verification-1.3.xsd">
   <configuration>
      <verify-metadata>true</verify-metadata>
      <verify-signatures>true</verify-signatures>
      <ignored-keys>
         <ignored-key id="abcdef1234567890" reason="Key is not available in any key server"/>
      </ignored-keys>
   </configuration>
</verification-metadata>
----

Once a key is ignored, it will not be used for verification even if the signature file mentions it.
However, if the signature cannot be verified with at least one other key, Gradle will require you to provide a checksum.

NOTE: If Gradle cannot download a key while bootstrapping, it will automatically mark it as ignored. If you can find the key but Gradle cannot, you can manually add it to the keyring file.

[[sec:verification-metadata-hygiene]]
== Maintaining Verification Metadata

Once you've set up dependency verification, you'll need to maintain the verification metadata file and keyring files over time.
This includes cleaning up old entries, refreshing keys, and managing your local keyring for better performance.

[[cleaning_up_verification_file]]
=== Cleaning up the Verification File

If you do nothing, the dependency verification metadata will grow over time as you add new dependencies or change versions: Gradle will not automatically remove _unused_ entries from this file.
The reason is that there's no way for Gradle to know upfront if a dependency will effectively be used during the build or not.

As a consequence, adding dependencies or changing dependency versions can easily lead to more entries in the file while leaving unnecessary entries.

One option to clean up the file is to move the existing `verification-metadata.xml` file to a different location and call Gradle with the `--dry-run` mode: while not perfect (it will not notice dependencies only resolved at configuration time), it generates _a new file_ that you can compare with the existing one.

We need to move the existing file because both the bootstrapping mode and the dry-run mode are incremental: they copy information from the existing metadata verification file (in particular, trusted keys).

[[sec:refreshing-missing-keys]]
=== Refreshing Missing Keys

Gradle caches missing keys for 24 hours, meaning it will not attempt to re-download the missing keys for 24 hours after failing.

If you want to retry immediately, you can run with the `--refresh-keys` CLI flag:

[source,bash]
----
./gradlew build --refresh-keys
----

[[sec:add-manual-keyring]]
=== Adding Keys to the Keyring

If you have a public key that Gradle cannot download from key servers, you can manually add it to the keyring file.
This is useful when a key is not published to public key servers or when you want to avoid downloading keys repeatedly.

[[sec:add-ascii-keyring]]
==== For ASCII-Armored Format (.keys)

If you're using the ASCII-armored keyring format, you can add keys directly by appending them to the `gradle/verification-keyring.keys` file.

First, export the public key to a file:

[source,bash]
----
$ gpg --export --armor 8756C4F765C9AC3CB6B85D62379CE192D401AB61 > key.asc
----

Then append the key to your keyring file:

[source,bash]
----
$ cat key.asc >> gradle/verification-keyring.keys
----

[[sec:add-binary-keyring]]
==== For Binary Format (.gpg)

If you're using the binary keyring format, use GPG to import the key:

[source,bash]
----
$ gpg --no-default-keyring --keyring gradle/verification-keyring.gpg --import key.asc
----

Or import directly from a key server to the keyring:

[source,bash]
----
$ gpg --no-default-keyring --keyring gradle/verification-keyring.gpg --recv-keys 8756C4F765C9AC3CB6B85D62379CE192D401AB61
----

NOTE: Remember to use full 40-character fingerprint IDs when working with keys, not short or long IDs.

[[sec:local-keyring]]
=== Exporting Keys for Faster Verification

Gradle automatically downloads public keys from key servers, but this can be slow and requires everyone to download the same keys repeatedly.
To avoid this, you can export keys to a local keyring file that can be committed to version control.

[[keyring_file_formats]]
==== Keyring File Formats

Gradle supports two keyring formats:

* **Binary format** (`.gpg`) - Compact and can be updated via GPG commands, but not human-readable
* **ASCII-armored format** (`.keys`) - Human-readable, easy to edit manually, and produces readable diffs for code reviews

You can configure which format to use:

[source,xml]
----
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<verification-metadata xmlns="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification"
      xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
      xsi:schemaLocation="https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification https://schema.gradle.org/dependency-verification/dependency-verification-1.3.xsd">
   <configuration>
      <verify-metadata>true</verify-metadata>
      <verify-signatures>true</verify-signatures>
      <keyring-format>armored</keyring-format>
   </configuration>
</verification-metadata>
----

Available options are `armored` and `binary`.

Without `keyring-format` specified, if `gradle/verification-keyring.gpg` or `gradle/verification-keyring.keys` exists, Gradle will use it. The binary version (`.gpg`) takes precedence if both exist.

[[exporting_keys]]
==== Exporting Keys

To export all keys used during verification to the keyring file, run:

[source,bash]
----
$ ./gradlew --write-verification-metadata pgp,sha256 --export-keys
----

Unless `keyring-format` is specified, this generates both the binary and ASCII-armored files.
You should only commit one format to your project.

You can also export keys without updating the verification metadata:

[source,bash]
----
$ ./gradlew --export-keys
----

NOTE: This command will not report verification errors, only export keys.

[[committing_keyring_files]]
==== Committing Keyring Files

It's a good idea to commit the keyring file to version control (as long as you trust your VCS).

If you use the binary format with Git, add this to your `.gitattributes` file to ensure it's treated as binary:

[source,text]
----
*.gpg           binary
----

NOTE: Only public key packets and a single userId per key are stored. All other information (user attributes, signatures, etc.) is stripped from exported keys.

[[sec:understanding-signature-verification]]
== Understanding Signature Verification

Once signature verification is enabled, Gradle follows this workflow for each artifact:

// Really gradle uses gpg to try to recreate the hash and verify that the two hashes match

1. Attempts to download the corresponding `.asc` signature file
2. If the signature file exists:
* Looks for the keys in the keyring, if they are not there, automatically downloads the public keys needed for verification
* Verifies the artifact using the downloaded keys
* If signature verification passes, performs any additional checksum verification you configured
3. If the signature file is absent, falls back to checksum verification

This means Gradle's verification is stronger with signatures enabled than with checksums alone:

* If an artifact is signed with multiple keys, all of them must pass validation or the build fails
* If an artifact passes signature verification, any additional checksums configured for that artifact will also be checked

However, passing signature verification doesn't automatically mean you can trust the artifact—you must explicitly trust the keys by adding them to your verification metadata as shown in <<#sec:manual-update-metadata>>.

[[sec:bootstrapping-signature-verification]]
=== Bootstrapping with Signatures

When you bootstrap with signature verification enabled using `--write-verification-metadata pgp,sha256`, Gradle takes an _optimistic approach_ and assumes signature verification is sufficient.
However, you must still provide a fallback checksum algorithm (like `SHA256`) because not all artifacts are signed.

Gradle performs optimistic verification during bootstrapping and automatically:

* **Auto-adds trusted keys** - When signature verification passes, Gradle adds the key to the trusted keys list
* **Auto-adds ignored keys** - When a key cannot be downloaded from public key servers, Gradle marks it as ignored in the configuration
* **Auto-generates checksums** - For artifacts without signatures or with ignored keys, Gradle generates checksums using the fallback algorithm
* **Auto-groups keys** - Gradle attempts to group keys at the group level (in `<trusted-keys>`) rather than per-artifact to minimize configuration file size

WARNING: Bootstrapping takes an optimistic point of view that signature verification is enough. If you also care about integrity, you should first bootstrap using checksum verification, then re-bootstrap with signature verification. This ensures you have checksums for all artifacts before adding signatures.

If signature verification fails during bootstrapping, Gradle will automatically generate an ignored key entry but will warn you to investigate.
This commonly happens when POM files differ between repositories in non-meaningful ways.

[[sec:dealing-verification-failure]]
== Troubleshooting Verification Failures

Dependency verification can fail in different ways. This section explains how to deal with various cases.

[[missing_verification_metadata]]
=== Missing Verification Metadata

The simplest failure occurs when verification metadata is missing from the dependency verification file.
This happens when you update a dependency and new versions (and potentially transitive dependencies) are brought in.

Gradle will tell you what metadata is missing:

[source,text]
----
Execution failed for task ':compileJava'.
> Dependency verification failed for configuration ':compileClasspath':
    - On artifact commons-logging-1.2.jar (commons-logging:commons-logging:1.2) in repository 'MavenRepo': checksum is missing from verification metadata.
----

The missing module group is `commons-logging`, artifact name is `commons-logging`, and version is `1.2`.
You need to add an entry to the verification file:

[source,xml]
----
<component group="commons-logging" name="commons-logging" version="1.2">
   <artifact name="commons-logging-1.2.jar">
      <sha256 value="daddea1ea0be0f56978ab3006b8ac92834afeefbd9b7e4e6316fca57df0fa636" origin="official distribution"/>
   </artifact>
</component>
----

Alternatively, ask Gradle to generate the missing information using <<#sec:bootstrapping-verification,bootstrapping>>.
Existing information will be preserved—Gradle only adds missing verification metadata.

[[incorrect_checksums]]
=== Incorrect Checksums

A more serious issue is when checksum verification fails:

[source,text]
----
Execution failed for task ':compileJava'.
> Dependency verification failed for configuration ':compileClasspath':
    - On artifact commons-logging-1.2.jar (commons-logging:commons-logging:1.2) in repository 'MavenRepo': expected a 'sha256' checksum of '91f7a33096ea69bac2cbaf6d01feb934cac002c48d8c8cfa9c240b40f1ec21df' but was 'daddea1ea0be0f56978ab3006b8ac92834afeefbd9b7e4e6316fca57df0fa636'
----

Gradle shows the dependency, expected checksum (declared in metadata file), and actual computed checksum.

**This indicates a dependency may have been compromised.**
You must perform manual verification.
Several scenarios:

* **Dependency tampered in local cache** - Delete the file from cache and Gradle will re-download.
* **Dependency available in multiple sources with slightly different binaries** - Additional whitespace, timestamps, etc.
** Inform library maintainers about the issue
** Use <<#sec:trusting-several-checksums,`also-trust`>> to accept additional checksums
* **Dependency was compromised**
** Immediately inform library maintainers
** Notify repository maintainers

Note: A variation is _name squatting_ (GAV coordinates that look legit but differ by one character) or _repository shadowing_ (official GAV coordinates published in a malicious repository that comes first in your build).

[[untrusted_signatures]]
=== Untrusted Signatures

With signature verification enabled, Gradle verifies signatures but doesn't automatically trust them:

[source,text]
----
> Dependency verification failed for configuration ':compileClasspath':
    - On artifact javaparser-core-3.6.11.jar (com.github.javaparser:javaparser-core:3.6.11) in repository 'MavenRepo': Artifact was signed with key '379ce192d401ab61' (Bintray (by JFrog) <****>) and passed verification but the key isn't in your trusted keys list.
----

You need to verify if the key can be trusted, then refer to <<#sec:understanding-signature-verification,Understanding Signature Verification>> to declare trusted keys.

[[failed_signature_verification]]
=== Failed Signature Verification

If Gradle fails to verify a signature, you must take action because **this may indicate a compromised dependency**.

Gradle will fail with:

[source,text]
----
> Dependency verification failed for configuration ':compileClasspath':
    - On artifact javaparser-core-3.6.11.jar (com.github.javaparser:javaparser-core:3.6.11) in repository 'MavenRepo': Artifact was signed with key '379ce192d401ab61' (Bintray (by JFrog) <****>) but signature didn't match
----

Options:

1. Signature was wrong in the first place (happens frequently with dependencies published on different repositories)
2. Signature is correct but artifact has been compromised (local cache or remotely)

Go to the official site to verify if they publish signatures.
If they do, verify that Gradle's downloaded signature matches the published one.

If you've verified the dependency is not compromised and only the signature is wrong, declare an artifact-level key exclusion and provide a checksum.

[[handling_wrong_signatures]]
=== Handling Wrong Signatures

There are several options when you encounter a signature verification failure:

1. The signature was wrong in the first place, which happens frequently with dependencies published on different repositories.
2. The signature is correct but the artifact has been compromised (either in the local dependency cache or remotely).

The right approach here is to go to the official site of the dependency and see if they publish signatures for their artifacts.
If they do, verify that the signature that Gradle downloaded matches the one published.

NOTE: Artifacts are often signed with expired keys, which is not a problem for verification. Key expiry is meant to prevent signing with stolen keys. If an artifact was signed before the key expired, the signature is still valid.

If you have checked that the dependency is _not_ compromised and that it's "only" the signature which is wrong, you should declare an _artifact level key exclusion_:

[source,xml]
----
   <components>
       <component group="com.github.javaparser" name="javaparser-core" version="3.6.11">
          <artifact name="javaparser-core-3.6.11.pom">
             <ignored-keys>
                <ignored-key id="379ce192d401ab61" reason="internal repo has corrupted POM"/>
             </ignored-keys>
          </artifact>
       </component>
   </components>
----

However, if you only do so, Gradle will still fail because all keys for this artifact will be ignored and you didn't provide a checksum:

[source,xml]
----
   <components>
       <component group="com.github.javaparser" name="javaparser-core" version="3.6.11">
          <artifact name="javaparser-core-3.6.11.pom">
             <ignored-keys>
                <ignored-key id="379ce192d401ab61" reason="internal repo has corrupted POM"/>
             </ignored-keys>
             <sha256 value="a2023504cfd611332177f96358b6f6db26e43d96e8ef4cff59b0f5a2bee3c1e1"/>
          </artifact>
       </component>
   </components>
----
